• it VO
  • fr Français
  • en English
  • ar العربية
About us
  • In-depth
    • All
    • Features
    • Files
    • World
    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    Surrogacy in Spain: A shady business favored by administrative permissiveness 3/3

    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    The transnational network of the surrogacy industry 1/3

    The transnational network of the surrogacy industry 1/3

    Arts: The women who are shifting the lines

    Arts: The women who are shifting the lines

    The jewelry of Palestinian artist Inas Dajani: When female genitalia inspire art

    The jewelry of Palestinian artist Inas Dajani: When female genitalia inspire art

    Trending Tags

    • Women artists
    • Ecofeminism
    • Women living from and on the streets
    • Women and bodies
    • Women and sports
    • Women and cinema
    • Ramadan series
    • Women and war
    • Women Living at the Margins
    • Press Freedom from the Perspective of Women Journalists
    • Period poverty
    • Gynecological violence
    • Women and prison
    • Safe spaces
    • Abortion and SRHR
    • Transgenderism
    • Women in rural areas
  • On the move
    Unequal belonging: Migration, identity, and the politics of citizenship in Italy

    Unequal belonging: Migration, identity, and the politics of citizenship in Italy

    Sexist discourse in the Greek public sphere: The targeting of leading women investigating a political tragedy

    Sexist discourse in the Greek public sphere: The targeting of leading women investigating a political tragedy

    A history of ecofeminism: At the origin were the witches

    A history of ecofeminism: At the origin were the witches

    Ecofeminism, an alternative to reenchant the world?

    Ecofeminism, an alternative to reenchant the world?

  • Portraits
    Kurdish journalist killed in Turkish drone strike in northeastern Syria

    Kurdish journalist killed in Turkish drone strike in northeastern Syria

    A Filmmaker’s Journey: Inside the Creative World of Margarita Bareikyte

    A Filmmaker’s Journey: Inside the Creative World of Margarita Bareikyte

    An interview with Tesh Sidi: Migrants in Parliament and inclusion by identity

    An interview with Tesh Sidi: Migrants in Parliament and inclusion by identity

    Interview with queer activist Marianne Chbat: “Our presence in academic settings is a militant act”

  • Creations
    • All
    • Reviews
    • Visual Arts
    Atlantics, a film by Mati Diop: Filming the embodied resistance of spirits

    Atlantics, a film by Mati Diop: Filming the embodied resistance of spirits

    All We Imagine as Light : three intertwined female stories

    All We Imagine as Light : three intertwined female stories

    Three Feminist Podcasts from the Southern Mediterranean

    Three Feminist Podcasts from the Southern Mediterranean

    Fotonica’s stereotype-free images

    Fotonica’s stereotype-free images

  • Opinion
    Messages from life under bombardment—No cake for my children on their birthdays (9)

    Messages from life under bombardment—No cake for my children on their birthdays (9)

    Messages from life under bombardment – No food or water in Gaza (8)

    Messages from life under bombardment – No food or water in Gaza (8)

    Goodbye Fatima, reporter of the ongoing Genocide in Gaza

    Goodbye Fatima, reporter of the ongoing Genocide in Gaza

    Fatima Hassouna’s “Loud Death”

    Fatima Hassouna’s “Loud Death”

  • Multimedia
    "I hope it doesn’t go viral: Journalism and sexist attacks in digital age". A video investigation by Çiçek Tahaoğlu

    "I hope it doesn’t go viral: Journalism and sexist attacks in digital age". A video investigation by Çiçek Tahaoğlu

    Period poverty in Montenegro

    Period poverty in Montenegro

    Period poverty in France (1)

    Period poverty in France (1)

    Period Poverty in Italy

    Period Poverty in Italy

  • Country context
No Result
View All Result
BLOGS
Medfeminiswiya
  • In-depth
    • All
    • Features
    • Files
    • World
    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    Surrogacy in Spain: A shady business favored by administrative permissiveness 3/3

    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    Greece and the problems of altruistic surrogacy 2/3

    The transnational network of the surrogacy industry 1/3

    The transnational network of the surrogacy industry 1/3

    Arts: The women who are shifting the lines

    Arts: The women who are shifting the lines

    The jewelry of Palestinian artist Inas Dajani: When female genitalia inspire art

    The jewelry of Palestinian artist Inas Dajani: When female genitalia inspire art

    Trending Tags

    • Women artists
    • Ecofeminism
    • Women living from and on the streets
    • Women and bodies
    • Women and sports
    • Women and cinema
    • Ramadan series
    • Women and war
    • Women Living at the Margins
    • Press Freedom from the Perspective of Women Journalists
    • Period poverty
    • Gynecological violence
    • Women and prison
    • Safe spaces
    • Abortion and SRHR
    • Transgenderism
    • Women in rural areas
  • On the move
    Unequal belonging: Migration, identity, and the politics of citizenship in Italy

    Unequal belonging: Migration, identity, and the politics of citizenship in Italy

    Sexist discourse in the Greek public sphere: The targeting of leading women investigating a political tragedy

    Sexist discourse in the Greek public sphere: The targeting of leading women investigating a political tragedy

    A history of ecofeminism: At the origin were the witches

    A history of ecofeminism: At the origin were the witches

    Ecofeminism, an alternative to reenchant the world?

    Ecofeminism, an alternative to reenchant the world?

  • Portraits
    Kurdish journalist killed in Turkish drone strike in northeastern Syria

    Kurdish journalist killed in Turkish drone strike in northeastern Syria

    A Filmmaker’s Journey: Inside the Creative World of Margarita Bareikyte

    A Filmmaker’s Journey: Inside the Creative World of Margarita Bareikyte

    An interview with Tesh Sidi: Migrants in Parliament and inclusion by identity

    An interview with Tesh Sidi: Migrants in Parliament and inclusion by identity

    Interview with queer activist Marianne Chbat: “Our presence in academic settings is a militant act”

  • Creations
    • All
    • Reviews
    • Visual Arts
    Atlantics, a film by Mati Diop: Filming the embodied resistance of spirits

    Atlantics, a film by Mati Diop: Filming the embodied resistance of spirits

    All We Imagine as Light : three intertwined female stories

    All We Imagine as Light : three intertwined female stories

    Three Feminist Podcasts from the Southern Mediterranean

    Three Feminist Podcasts from the Southern Mediterranean

    Fotonica’s stereotype-free images

    Fotonica’s stereotype-free images

  • Opinion
    Messages from life under bombardment—No cake for my children on their birthdays (9)

    Messages from life under bombardment—No cake for my children on their birthdays (9)

    Messages from life under bombardment – No food or water in Gaza (8)

    Messages from life under bombardment – No food or water in Gaza (8)

    Goodbye Fatima, reporter of the ongoing Genocide in Gaza

    Goodbye Fatima, reporter of the ongoing Genocide in Gaza

    Fatima Hassouna’s “Loud Death”

    Fatima Hassouna’s “Loud Death”

  • Multimedia
    "I hope it doesn’t go viral: Journalism and sexist attacks in digital age". A video investigation by Çiçek Tahaoğlu

    "I hope it doesn’t go viral: Journalism and sexist attacks in digital age". A video investigation by Çiçek Tahaoğlu

    Period poverty in Montenegro

    Period poverty in Montenegro

    Period poverty in France (1)

    Period poverty in France (1)

    Period Poverty in Italy

    Period Poverty in Italy

  • Country context
About us
Medfeminiswiya
About us

Does the trans revolution obliterate women?

A magazine cover announcing a baby bump, a new life… but this time the pregnant person wore a beard and moustache. “Diversity is a source of enrichment,” reads the headline. Something is not right about this, argues Monica from Italy.

Monica Lanfranco by Monica Lanfranco
15 November 2021
in Opinion
6 1
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

While I was preparing the audio recording for the Rai3 wikiradio on the Pierobon trial, a milestone for the launch of the Law 194 allowing voluntary interruption of pregnancy at the beginning of the 70s, I came across the complaint for ‘contempt of religion’ which the weekly magazine, the Espresso, was faced with for its stark cover of 1975. It was the image of a pregnant woman, naked and nailed to a cross, with the accompanying title Abortion, an Italian tragedy. A strong and clear message recalling that millions of women in Italy were forced to abort illegally with huge risks of septicemia, bleeding, sterility and death.

One cannot but remember this cover when seeing what the same weekly magazine published mid-2021: a cover announcing a baby bump, a life that will be born, a baby on the way, but this time the pregnant person on the 2021 cover designed by Fumettibrutti, wore a beard and moustache. “Diversity is a source of enrichment,” reads the headline, written in felt-pen on the belly.

To give greater prominence to the iconographic choice, the cover headline connects what I perceive as oxymoronic ‘male maternity’ with the rights at work. On the website of the Espresso, we read that the cover story is a long in-depth focus on the ongoing struggles for civil rights and the right to work, making it look as if the Zan law - a bill against homotransphobia criticized by parts of the feminist movement and recently rejected by Parliament- and the fight for employment protection, were two sides of the same coin.

The fact that diversity is a source of enrichment is undeniable. Upsetting patriarchal culture has always been the clear claim and objective of feminism. The aim was to break the universal granitic masculine that presumably encompassed every other identity and wiped, especially the feminine, off the world, from language and culture to law and representation; and to clearly state that the primary difference with which to rewrite the human narrative should be one based on women’s accounts, experiences and views.

The main pressing question for me was: When did diversity start meaning that maternity can be falsely presented through a pregnant person with a beard and moustache, or in other words, a man, according to the more subtle message of the cover?

The aim was to break the universal granitic masculine that presumably encompassed every other identity and wiped, especially the feminine, off the world

It is worth noting that this cover was not an exclusive investigation carried out by the Espresso revealing the centuries old deception in which women have grown up to be “the sex that envied the penis,” to perhaps prove that it is men who have felt jealous of the uterus and the peculiar female generative capacity. So, what was the message behind the cover?

While it is important to take time to understand what these symbols and words meant, one thing was certain for me: the weekly magazine clearly emphasized the connection between the somewhat shaky theme of ‘male motherhood’ with the much more solid demand of labor rights (worth mentioning that it was actually a man who was interviewed on this matter). The cover reminded me of another image evoking the fact that ‘nothing is inconceivable’. This was the slogan of the light comedy Junior, where the very unfeminine Arnold Schwarzenegger gets pregnant. It also took me back to the story of two transgender activists who have decided to tell the world about their encounter, their transition journey and their desire to start a family. Trystan and Biff, a man and a woman in transition from Portland, Oregon who adopted Hailey and Riley. But then at some point, the woman of the couple stops the medical treatment and becomes pregnant in 2018.

Like millions of VIP couples, Trystan and Biff document their pregnancy and post about it on their facebook, instagram and youtube channels. However, in the particular case of this couple, the two parties erase the woman and her motherhood and speak only of themselves as two men: ‘two men made a baby,’ stands out in their social media ‘male pregnancy’ campaign. ‘We are two dads,’ is how the birth is announced. In their video, shared shortly after Leo’s birth, the father says: “Next time someone tells you a man cannot give birth, show them this video.” From the hospital bed, the mother smiles approving this thought: “Because I did it!”

https://medfeminiswiya.net/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/TWO-MEN-MADE-A-BABY.mp4

I do not know where to start from to express my dismay. Should I highlight the mystifying arrogance I sense in denying evidence, and therefore paving the way for the suppression of the female body, by those who have just given birth? Or should I point out the probable delusion of omnipotence shared by Trystan and Biff who, in adherence and celebration of the possibilities self-perception allows, falsify facts by completely nullifying the female body?

If one pays close attention to the materials produced by this couple -presented as a training agency for schools to tell children about what a true loving family is- one cannot but notice their obsession to emphasize and promote the fact that they are two men, two fathers. And in my view, this is a puzzling manifesto of women’s elimination, of the elimination of the feminine of the world, in the name of trans perfection, finally self-generating, albeit through a heavily misogynistic lens.

Facebook page: Biff and I

The couple’s campaign is centered around The trans revolution, a type of revolution that is disturbing many, not because diversity is uncomfortable to them, to us, but rather because it is far from celebrating diversity when in fact it is succeeding in eliminating its origins.

Tags: Transgenderism
Monica Lanfranco

Monica Lanfranco

Monica Lanfranco is an Italian journalist, blogger, trainer and founder of the feminist quarterly “Marea” in 1994. She is the creator of the Radio Delle Donne podcast channel, has taught new media theory and technique at the University of Parma, and has been running the feminist training and seminar center, Altradimora, since 2008. Monica is also a book author, and her latest book, "Crescere uomini-le parole dei ragazzi su sessualità, pornografia, sessismo" (Growing up as a man: Teenagers' words about sexuality, pornography and sexism), was published by Erickson in 2019. Follow Monica’s work on her personal website: Monica Lanfranco, Radio Delle donne, Marea, Altradimora, Il Fatto Quotidiano.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

J'accepte les termes et conditions et la Politique de confidentialité .

Medfeminiswiya

Medfeminiswiya is a feminist network that brings together women journalists working in the fields of media and content production in the Mediterranean region.

Newsletter


    Follow us

    Browse topics


    • In-depth
    • Files
    • Features
    • On the move
    • Portraits
    • Opinion

    • Creations
    • Visual Arts
    • Reviews
    • Multimedia
    • Country Context
    • Blogs
    • About us
    • Our community
    • Our partners
    • Become a member
    • Editorial charter
    • Disclaimer

    © 2023 Medfeminiswiya - Mediterranean Network for Feminist Information

    • it VO
    • fr Français
    • en English
    • ar العربية
    • In-depth
    • On the move
    • Portraits
    • Creations
    • Opinion
    • Multimedia
    • Country context
    • Blogs
    No Result
    View All Result

    © 2023 Medfeminiswiya - Mediterranean Network for Feminist Information

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password?

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Add New Playlist

    Ce site n'utilise pas de cookies. This website does not use cookies. هذا الموقع لا يستخدم ملفات تعريف الارتباط.